Beckman, Emily
Nelson, Elizabeth
Labode, Modupe
Article History
First Online: 21 May 2020
Compliance with Ethical Standards
: No funding was received to conduct the research in this article
: Dr. Emily Beckman declares that she has no conflict of interest.Dr. Elizabeth Nelson declares that she has no conflict of interest.Dr. Modupe Labode declares that she has no conflict of interest.
: This article does not contain any studies with animals performed by any of the authors.
: This article is based on publicly available archival materials and as such, falls outside of the purview of the authors’ Institutional Review Board. The authors have not been able to trace the patients who wrote articles for <i>The DDU Review</i>. To preserve the anonymity of writers while also acknowledging the importance of each individual’s production, the authors have referred to the individual authors by their first name and the initial of their surname (for example, Linda S.).
: <sup>1 </sup>The Indiana Medical History Museum’s collection of Central State Hospital newsletters also includes <i>The Central Observer</i> (1970-1971) and <i>The Local Bahr</i> (1991–1993). <i>The DDU Review</i> holdings include forty-two issues published from September 1988 until September 1993. The earliest issues (dating from October 1986-August 1988, along with January 1991–June 1991 and July–August 1992) have not been located.<sup>2 </sup>As Reiss (2004, 23, f.n. 5) notes: “Erving Goffman wrote that ‘house organs’—newsletters written by patients—are little more than vehicles for patients to voice ‘the institutional line’ on issues affecting their lives (96). Jann Matlock, writing about a nineteenth-century woman’s surreptitious asylum journal, arrives at an equally sweeping but precisely opposite conclusion: ‘Writing in the asylum is always transgression. It is always an attempt to get beyond the asylum, to make sense out of being locked up, to reclaim an identity other than the one conferred by the system, to procure an inviolable space’ (168–69).” Reiss is referencing Erving Goffman (1961) <i>Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates</i> (New York: Doubleday) and Jann Matlock (1991) “Doubling Out of the Crazy House: Gender, Autobiography, and the Insane Asylum System in Nineteenth-Century France,” <i>Representations</i> 34 (1991):166-195.<sup>3</sup>See, for example, Kathleen Brian’s elegant examination of the appropriation of medical discourse—in this case, the nascent language of eugenics—in Anna Agnew’s institutional memoir <i>From Under the Cloud, or Personal Reminscences of Insanity</i> (1886), a text also created by a patient at Central State, then called the Indiana Hospital for the Insane.<sup>4 </sup>Indeed, psychiatric hospitals in particular have incorporated rehabilitative techniques that exceed the purely biomedical since the advent of the “moral treatment” in the mid-nineteenth century.<sup>5 </sup>As of 2010, these facilities are called Intermediate Care Facilities for Individuals with Intellectual Disabilities (ICF/IID).<sup>6 </sup>Today, Bonnie Leftridge is known as Bonnie O’Connor.<sup>7 </sup>The authors have not been able to trace the patients who wrote articles for <i>The DDU Review</i>. To preserve the anonymity of writers while also acknowledging the importance of each individual’s production, the authors have referred to the individual authors by their first name and the initial of their surname (for example, Linda S.).<sup>8 </sup>Ryan White (1971-1990) used his experience of living with HIV/AIDS to fight discrimination and stigma against people with HIV/AIDS. Many celebrities who supported his activism attended his funeral in Indianapolis. In 1992, heavyweight boxing champion Mike Tyson was convicted of raping an eighteen-year-old woman. The trial was held in Indianapolis, where the crime occurred in July 1991. The national media extensively covered both events.<sup>9 </sup>Having “full grounds” was the hospital’s term for a level of privilege in which the resident was permitted having the privilege to move freely throughout the entire hospital grounds on their own.